You applied for the job you were not qualified for. You texted the person who has not texted back. You said, out loud, to a friend, "it's going to work out", and some small part of you believed it.
Delulu is the solulu, says the internet, and it has a point, and also you have a friend who has been "manifesting" the same man for three years. The trick is knowing which one you are.
Is a little delusion actually healthy?
Psychologists have been asking this since before the slang. In a much-cited 1988 paper, Shelley Taylor and Jonathon Brown argued that mentally healthy people tend to hold positive illusions: a slightly inflated view of themselves, an exaggerated sense of control, and more optimism about the future than the facts strictly allow.
Their uncomfortable finding was that the people with the most accurate self-assessment were often the mildly depressed. Accuracy, it turned out, is not the same as wellbeing.
Neuroscientist Tali Sharot later put a number on the optimism part. In her review of the optimism bias, she notes that about 80% of people show it. Her example: couples about to marry know the divorce statistics and still rate their own odds as negligible.
So a bit delulu is normal. The question is what the delusion is for.
A hopeful distortion is not a bug in the mind; it is one of the mind's load-bearing walls.
Where does delulu turn into denial?
Here is the line, as best I can draw it. Healthy illusion points toward something and gets you to act. Denial points away from something and keeps you still.
Sharot's brides are not deluded in a harmful way, because the belief makes them show up for the marriage. Your friend manifesting a man who left is in trouble, not because she hopes, but because the hope is doing the work that grieving should be doing.
The tell is usually in the body. Healthy optimism feels like leaning forward. Denial feels like holding your breath.
If the dream makes you move, keep it; if the dream keeps you from moving, it is not a dream, it is a hiding place.
The evidence-based version of delulu
Psychologist Gabriele Oettingen spent two decades testing what positive fantasy actually does, and her results were awkward for the vision-board industry. In Rethinking Positive Thinking, she reports that pure positive fantasising tends to lower effort and results: the brain gets a taste of the outcome and relaxes, as if it were already done.
What works instead is what she calls mental contrasting. Picture the wish, then picture the obstacle in you that stands in the way. Her practical version is WOOP: Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan.
Notice that this is still delulu. You still get to want the thing out loud. You just do not stop at the fantasy; you turn and look at the wall.
Hope with an obstacle in it is a plan; hope without one is a nap.
Amélie and the uses of a well-placed fantasy
Jean-Pierre Jeunet's Amélie is, on the surface, a two-hour argument for delulu. Amélie rearranges other people's lives with little anonymous schemes and the whole of Montmartre glows with it.
But watch what the film actually does with her. Her imagination works beautifully on everyone except herself. She can engineer a stranger's happiness and cannot cross a café to speak to a man she likes. Her fantasy life is rich precisely in the place where her real life is empty. The glass man upstairs, who cannot leave his flat, is the one who finally says it: go to him.
That is the whole distinction in one film. Delusion in the service of others, or of a future you are walking toward, is generous. Delusion as a substitute for the one scary conversation is just a nicer-looking wall.
The question is never whether you imagine too much; it is whether you imagine instead.
Try this with a card
Metaphoric cards are structured imagination. They let you be delulu on purpose, for ten minutes, with an exit.
- Draw. Pull one card while holding your wish in mind, the one you are a bit embarrassed about. Do not choose; let it arrive.
- Look. Let the image be the wish fulfilled for a moment. Notice how your body responds. Lean forward, or breath held?
- Two questions. Ask the card: what in me is the obstacle? Then: what is the smallest move I could make this week, with the obstacle still there?
That second question is where Oettingen's research and a deck of pictures meet. The wish is allowed. The wall is allowed. The plan is small enough to survive both.
If the hoping has started to feel like the only thing keeping a loss at bay, or if the gap between what you believe and what is happening is making people around you worried, that is a kind moment to talk to a therapist.
Otherwise, go on, draw a card. Be a little delulu. Then take one step.