← all posts

A red-haired trader celebrates a big win on the trading floor while a few colleagues cheer and many others watch with envy.

Envy as Information: The Feeling You're Not Allowed to Have

A friend posts the news. The book deal, the house, the baby, the trip. You type "so happy for you" and you mean it, roughly. Then you put the phone face down and feel something small and acidic that you would rather not name.

That is envy. It is probably the most common emotion you have never said out loud, and envy as information might be the most useful idea you have not been given.

Why is envy so hard to admit?

Of the classic seven deadly sins, envy is the only one with no pleasure in it. Gluttony has the meal. Lust has the lust. Envy is just pain at someone else's good fortune, which is why we hide it even from ourselves, often by converting it into something more respectable: criticism, indifference, a sudden interest in the flaws of the person we envy.

Psychoanalyst Melanie Klein made envy central in Envy and Gratitude, published in 1957. Her claim, stripped of the theory, is that envy begins very early, attacks the very thing we need, and is the enemy of gratitude. You cannot be grateful for what you are busy spoiling.

Envy hides because it tells the truth about what you lack.

Are there two kinds of envy?

Yes, and the distinction changes everything. Dutch researchers Niels van de Ven, Marcel Zeelenberg and Rik Pieters, in a 2009 paper in the journal Emotion titled Leveling up and down, showed across three countries that people experience two distinct envies. Benign envy carries a moving-up motivation: I want that, so I will work toward it. Malicious envy carries a pulling-down motivation: I want that, so I would rather they lost it.

Same trigger, opposite direction. The feeling that seems so shameful is only shameful in one of its forms.

Amadeus is a two-and-a-half-hour study in the malicious kind. Salieri does not want to write like Mozart. He wants Mozart not to exist. What makes the film unbearable is that Salieri is the only person in Vienna who fully understands how good the music is. His envy is accurate. It is his response to it, the spoiling and sabotage and the long slide into bitterness, that destroys him. The tragedy is a man who had perfect information and used it to level down.

Envy is not the problem. What you do with the direction is.

What does social media do to envy?

It industrialises it. A 2015 study in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General by Philippe Verduyn and colleagues, Passive Facebook usage undermines affective well-being, found that scrolling without interacting lowered people's mood over time, and that the mechanism was envy. Not the posting. The watching.

A feed is a curated stream of other people's level-ups, delivered without context and without your own life in the frame for comparison. That is an envy machine. Noticing that does not make the feeling go away, but it does make it less personal.

If the scroll leaves you sour, the sourness is data about the scroll, not about your worth.

How do you turn envy into a want?

Gestalt therapy has a plain move for this: own the wish. Envy is a want that has been handed to someone else. You see the thing in their life and feel it as their property rather than your desire. The work is to take it back.

Try saying it in the first person. Not "she is so lucky" but "I want a life where I make things." Not "he got the promotion" but "I want to be trusted with more." The sentence will feel exposed. That exposure is the point. A wish you can say is a wish you can act on, or grieve, or decide you do not need after all. A wish you cannot say just sits in your stomach and sours.

Try this with a card

Envy is easier to look at sideways than head-on.

  1. Draw a card while holding the person you envy in mind. Do not pick; take what comes.
  2. Look at the image slowly. Find the part of it that seems to have something you do not. Notice where the feeling sits in your body.
  3. Ask two questions. What do they have that I want? Then, the harder one: What is the smallest version of that I could move toward this month?

Write the second answer down. You now have a want with your name on it. The Pentagram can help you see which part of your life it belongs to.

Envy, read correctly, is a compass. It points at what matters to you and nobody else.

If envy has hardened into resentment that colours most of your relationships, or you find yourself wishing for others to fail more than wishing for yourself to grow, that is a pattern worth untangling with a therapist.

Until then, you could draw a card and ask it what you want.

Share Telegram WhatsApp
This post published itself at 9:00 — like every post here. See how →

← all posts