I've been thinking for quite some time about how we learn. Or, more precisely, about what happens between two people when one of them knows something and the other has come to learn it.
And it seems to me that we're still swinging on a rather fascinating historical pendulum.
There was a time when education often resembled a peculiar kind of pedagogical survivality. Strict discipline, unquestioning obedience to authority, and sometimes outright violence and humiliation were somehow presented as necessary conditions for becoming a respectable human being.
I remember older relatives telling stories about their wonderful teachers. "Oh, he was strict, but fair!" And sometimes they said it with such admiration that you might have thought a teacher's ability to give a student a nervous breakdown was a remarkable professional achievement.
I attended a Soviet school myself. I remember those little green notebooks, the lovely grades, and the red ink teachers used to correct our mistakes.
And here's something interesting: even when there were only a few mistakes, those red marks could feel like tiny public defeats. As though it wasn't your punctuation or mathematical expression being corrected, but you.
You made a mistake. Therefore, something must be wrong with you.
But excuse me, what the hell?
At what point did making a mistake while learning become a measure of someone's worth as a human being?
A person who solves an equation incorrectly hasn't become a worse person. Someone who struggles to remember a foreign word hasn't suddenly become less intelligent or less worthy. And someone who completes an assignment perfectly hasn't automatically acquired moral superiority over everyone else.
Of course, abilities differ. Some people understand mathematics almost intuitively. Others have an extraordinary ear for linguistic structures. And some need considerably more time, repetition, and explanation.
That's perfectly normal. We're not identical.
But here's what interests me even more: how does pedagogical authority turn a mistake from useful information into a verdict?
After all, the relationship between teacher and student really is asymmetrical. One person possesses knowledge, professional experience, the authority to evaluate, and sometimes even the power to influence another person's educational opportunities.
And that creates an enormous temptation to confuse competence with superiority.
I know more, therefore I am above you.
I've explained it, therefore you're obliged to understand.
I've invested my effort, therefore your mistake is practically a personal insult to my pedagogical greatness.
My magnificent image is flawless. I've delivered the material perfectly. If you haven't understood it, the problem is obviously you.
And this is where things become particularly interesting to me as a psychotherapist.
Because education doesn't involve two machines exchanging information. It involves two human beings, each with their own history, nervous system, expectations, and ways of dealing with shame, anxiety, aggression, and feelings of inadequacy.
A teacher can be tired, anxious, frustrated, or insecure. A student can be overwhelmed, frightened, distracted, or simply not ready to absorb a particular piece of information at a particular moment.
And when these two states meet, sometimes learning happens.
And sometimes a small struggle for power begins.
But our pendulum has another extreme.
After a long history of authoritarian education, we quite understandably began talking about kindness, respect, psychological safety, and individual differences.
And that's wonderful.
However, I sometimes feel that in certain educational environments, we risk confusing psychological safety with the need to protect people from every unpleasant experience.
Don't upset them. Don't frustrate them. Don't point out mistakes too directly. Don't set expectations that might cause discomfort.
And then something rather strange happens: in our determination to protect people from the experience of failure, we may deprive them of one of the most important tools of learning.
The opportunity to discover that there is something they cannot do yet.
But frustration, in itself, is not violence.
I can tell a student, "You've made a mistake here. Let's look at why," while continuing to treat them with respect, curiosity, and warmth.
I can set expectations without humiliating someone. I can identify weaknesses in a piece of work without devaluing its author. I can be persistent without becoming cruel.
In fact, sometimes it is precisely this encounter with a limitation that creates the possibility of growth.
I enjoy looking at this through the lens of Gestalt therapy.
Imagine someone has completed an assignment. They've invested effort, produced a result, and experienced satisfaction. For them, a particular process feels complete.
And then I appear, the teacher, with my feedback.
"Look, there's something here worth revisiting."
And suddenly, a familiar figure emerges into the foreground again. Something that seemed complete becomes material for a new contact, a new exploration, a new way of acting.
This is my own interpretation of the experience through the Gestalt cycle of contact, and I find it fascinating.
Because correcting a mistake, in this sense, doesn't erase the previous experience.
It allows that experience to be transformed.
Now, let me offer another metaphor.
Recently, I was talking to a high school student, and I found myself feeling genuinely sad.
I think school could be an enormous, beautiful tray filled with extraordinary treasures: precious stones, strange fruits, ancient manuscripts, instruments, plants, mysterious mechanisms you want to touch, take apart, smell, taste, and understand.
You don't yet know what to do with them. Perhaps you won't like everything. Perhaps some things will be too difficult.
But how exciting it could be to explore!
Instead, education often turns into a compulsory three-course meal.
Here's your starter. Here's your main course. Here's dessert. Portions approved. Timetable established. Eat.
It doesn't matter whether you're hungry. It doesn't matter whether you're currently capable of digesting what's being served. It doesn't matter whether you're interested in what's on your plate.
Of course, education cannot consist exclusively of things we find pleasant or exciting. Sometimes we need to master something difficult, boring, or fundamental before we can gain access to something genuinely fascinating.
But why not learn to prepare and serve this intellectual food in a way that gradually helps people develop an appetite for it?
Small portions. Opportunities to try, make mistakes, return, and ask questions. An understanding that different people absorb information differently.
And here, somewhat unexpectedly, I discovered a fascinating parallel with the world of IT.
I'm currently learning software development and exploring project management, Scrum, sprints, iterations, testing, and debugging.
And I'm absolutely captivated by the underlying philosophy of working with an imperfect result.
You create something. You test it. You discover a discrepancy. You analyse it. You correct it. You try again.
None of this means that every mistake is wonderful or that we should deliberately produce poor-quality work. But the opportunity to discover imperfections and adapt our actions is built into the very logic of the process.
So why shouldn't we approach human learning in a similar way?
We breathe. We eat. We sleep. We forget. We get tired. We make mistakes.
And sometimes we make absolutely spectacular ones.
Sometimes you look at the result of your own efforts and realise: well, shit. We've really screwed this one up. Spectacularly. With imagination.
And now what?
We could spend the rest of our lives contemplating the catastrophe and punishing ourselves for it.
Or we could figure out what happened, clean up the mess, learn something, and carry on.
Personally, I find the second option considerably more productive.
And this brings me back to ethics.
Not ethics as a collection of beautiful words, but ethics as something that lives in actual human contact.
My competence does not make me a more valuable human being than my student. Their lack of knowledge does not make them a less valuable human being than me.
I can offer knowledge. They can receive it, process it, explore it, reject it, return to it, and create something of their own.
Our roles are different. Our knowledge is different. But human dignity is not distributed according to the number of correct answers.
And by the way, returning to those little green school notebooks of mine...
Sometimes I wonder: what if, alongside all those red corrections, teachers had used a little more green ink?
Not a meaningless "Well done!" on every page, but something specific:
"Look, you've found an interesting solution here."
"This particular thought is especially precise."
"Notice how much you've improved in this section."
So that a person could see not only the distance between themselves and an ideal result, but also the distance they had already travelled.
As far as I remember, there wasn't any particular shortage of green ink.
For some reason, red simply seemed to be in much greater pedagogical demand.
Today, I continue to be a student myself.
I take professional courses, explore new approaches in psychotherapy, learn IT, and thoroughly enjoy observing how differently software developers, project managers, and psychotherapists think.
And I have wonderful teachers. People whose competence is accompanied by curiosity, respect, and a genuine ability to meet the person who has come to learn.
There are also those who disappoint me.
Not that my initial admiration always reached the height of Mount Everest, but still, disappointment can be rather sad.
However, I now have a certain luxury: I can choose whom I learn from.
I can notice which approaches to teaching work for me and which don't. I can respect someone's expertise without necessarily agreeing with their teaching style.
And of course, I won't always be the perfect student myself.
I won't always be precise, attentive, or consistent. My code won't always run. My professional interpretations won't always be successful. I'll make mistakes, reconsider, return, and try again.
And there is nothing humiliating about that.
Because this is the result of my work.
Sometimes, the result of both my work and my teacher's.
And I genuinely hope that, little by little, we can learn to see education not as an endless examination of our worth as human beings, but as a shared encounter with the unknown.
A place where we can be demanding without becoming cruel. Gentle without becoming helpless. Competent without turning competence into a pedestal.
Where a mistake remains a mistake, and a human being remains a human being.
And perhaps the most beautiful thing a good teacher can teach us is not merely how to solve problems correctly, but how to stop being afraid of discovering that we don't yet know how to solve them.
Do you remember a teacher you weren't afraid to make mistakes around? What did they do differently?