← all posts

An enthusiastic therapist points to a board of things clients can do in therapy, while an older male client smiles with surprise and relief.

What If I Cry, Go Silent, or Lie to You?

You're curious — and, if we're honest, rehearsing. What if you cry in the first ten minutes? What if you sit there with nothing to say? What if, as you have every intention of doing, you leave a few things out?

Welcome. You'll do all three. Here's what happens.

If I cry

Then you cry. Nobody flinches, nobody says "oh no, don't", nobody passes the tissues with the speed of someone trying to stop a leak. The box is within reach and you'll find it yourself. The therapist stays where they are, which is the whole technique.

People apologise for crying more than for anything else in a therapy room, and the apology is interesting — it says something about where you learned that tears were an inconvenience. But the tears themselves? They're often the first sentence in the session that wasn't rehearsed. The body gets there before the words do; it usually does.

Crying isn't the interruption of the conversation. It frequently is the conversation.

If I go silent

Then there is silence, and it is allowed. The therapist won't fill it with questions to rescue you both, won't look at the clock, won't take it personally. Something is almost always happening in the quiet — you're deciding whether to say the thing, or you've just felt something you don't have a word for yet, or you're waiting to be rescued because that's what people have always done. All three are work.

Silence in therapy is different from silence at a dinner party. At the dinner party it means something has gone wrong. In the room it often means something has gone right and needs a minute.

If it gets unbearable, say so: "I don't know what to say." That sentence is never a dead end. It's a door.

You don't have to produce. Nothing is being graded. The quiet is yours.

If I lie

You will. Not dramatically — small things, in the first months. You'll round down the drinking, round up the exercise, describe the fight with your partner in a version where you were slightly more reasonable. You'll leave out the thing you came for and talk about something adjacent, and tell yourself you'll get to it next week.

This is not a scandal. It's what everybody does when they're not yet sure the room is safe. A therapist doesn't catch lies and confront them like a detective; that's television. They notice, maybe, that the story has a smooth patch where a rough one should be, and they wait. Sooner or later you say: "I wasn't completely honest about that." And the room doesn't fall down, and that moment — not the lie — is where therapy usually starts for real.

The lie is you checking the floor. The correction is you standing on it.

What if I want to quit after one session?

Then you can. A first session is a meeting, not a contract — the whole point of it is to decide. You owe no explanation, though a sentence is kind and useful ("it didn't feel right"). More on stopping, properly, in a later post. The short version: it's your right, it's never your job to justify, and a good therapist would rather you find your person than stay out of politeness.

What the therapist is actually doing

Sitting there, mostly. Not sitting there like a stone — sitting there like someone who has seen tears, silence and small lies many times and has stopped treating any of them as emergencies. Which is, when you think about it, a very specific skill, and the main reason people pay for the hour rather than talking to a friend. A friend would try to fix it. The therapist waits to see what it is.

The short version

Is it okay to cry in therapy?

Yes. Nobody will be embarrassed, nobody will rush you, and there is a box of tissues within reach for a reason. Crying is often the first honest thing that happens in a session.

What if I can't think of anything to say?

Silence is allowed and often useful. The therapist will not punish it or fill it with chatter. Something is usually happening in the quiet, and that is where the work is.

What if I lie to my therapist?

Most people do, especially early on — to look better, to protect someone, out of shame. The lie is not the end of therapy. The moment you can say "I wasn't honest about that" is usually the beginning.

Share Telegram WhatsApp
This post published itself at 9:00 — like every post here. See how →

A question, or a first session?

Tamara reads and answers every message herself, usually within the day. For booking and practical questions; the conversation itself happens in the session.

Or pick a time in the calendar →

← all posts