Your brother forgets your mother's birthday and gets a laugh. You forget it once, in 2019, and it still comes up. Or the reverse: you're the one who can do no wrong, and you've noticed how carefully you've arranged your life to keep it that way.
Golden child vs scapegoat isn't a diagnosis. It's a casting decision, usually made before anyone could audition. Understanding how a family hands out those parts is the first step to handing yours back.
How do families decide who's the golden child?
Family systems theory has a plain answer: anxiety needs somewhere to go. Murray Bowen, whose work is kept alive by the Bowen Center, described the triangle as the smallest stable unit in a family. Two people under strain pull in a third. A marriage that can't talk about itself talks about a child instead.
Which child? Often the one who most resembles the parent's own disowned parts, or the one whose temperament makes a convenient screen. Bowen called this the family projection process: the parent's worry lands on a particular kid and, over time, shapes them to fit it.
Salvador Minuchin, in Families and Family Therapy, added the architecture. Families have boundaries and subsystems, and when a child gets pulled into the parents' subsystem, as confidant, ally, or problem, the whole structure bends around them.
Nobody chose you for the role; the system needed a part filled, and you were standing nearest.
What research says about favouritism
You might assume the golden child wins. The data is less flattering.
A Cornell and Purdue study of 275 older mothers and 671 of their adult children found that perceived favouritism predicted more depressive symptoms in the adult children, whether they were the favoured one or not. Most mothers admitted having a closest child. Very few children thought treatment had been equal.
Reviews of parental differential treatment in adolescence tell a similar story: it's linked to more internalising and externalising problems and worse sibling relationships, not just for the child who got less.
Why would the golden child suffer? Because being chosen is conditional. You're loved for the function you serve: achiever, peacemaker, proof the family is fine. Step out of function and you find out fast what the love was attached to.
Favouritism costs both children; one pays in resentment, the other in a self they can't afford to put down.
The Roy children and the empty chair
Succession is four seasons of a casting call that never ends. Logan Roy doesn't just prefer a child; he rotates the preference, so that golden child and scapegoat are positions rather than people. Kendall is the heir on Tuesday and the disgrace by Friday. Shiv is the clever one until she's the naive one. Roman is the joke until, briefly, he isn't.
What the show understands is that the children keep auditioning. Even after Logan is gone, they circle the chair, fighting over who gets to sit in it, because the only self any of them knows is the one defined by his gaze.
That's the trap of the role. It can survive the person who assigned it.
The role is only alive while you keep performing it for an audience that may no longer be watching.
Can the roles be re-cast?
Yes, though rarely by announcement. Telling your family "I'm not the screw-up any more" tends to get filed under screw-up behaviour.
Roles shift when one person stops playing their half of the triangle. Bowen called this differentiation of self: staying connected to your family while thinking and acting from your own centre. Practically, it looks like declining to carry messages between parents. Letting your sibling's crisis be theirs. Saying something true at dinner and not managing the reaction.
Minuchin's approach was more theatrical. He'd rearrange the chairs, literally, to show a family its own structure. You can do a quieter version. Notice who you sit next to. Notice whose side you take before anyone has spoken.
Try this with a card
- Draw. Pull one metaphoric card while thinking of your family at a table.
- Look. Find the figure or object in the image that is most you. Then find the one that is most not you, the part you were never allowed to play.
- Ask two questions. What did my role protect the family from having to see? And: What would I do this month if I weren't auditioning?
The pentagram can help you see which areas of your life are still running on the old script.
Pick one small scene this month and play it as yourself rather than as the part.
If stepping out of your role brings up panic, a sudden depression, or a family backlash you can't weather alone, a family-informed therapist is the right companion for that.
Until then, draw a card. It has no favourites.